T.L. Gorbunova

Branch of the Institute of Natural and Technical Systems, RF, Sochi, Kurortny Av., 99/18


DOI: 10.33075/2220-5861-2019-3-51-59

UDC 574.631  


   This article focuses on developing and testing a complex multimetric index for assessment of the ecological state of the mountain water streams on the example of the rivers located on the Greater Sochi territory.

   The proposed index is a multifunctional indicator of various impact factors and includes criteria reflecting the state of macroinvertibrate communities of the natural water streams. Such index was developed for the environmental assessment of the water streams in the subtropical RF South region with dynamic development of the recreational and resort sector of the economy for the first time.

   The proposed multimetric index (MMI) is a weighted average of five constituent criteria: the Shannon and Margalef indexes of biodiversity, the Berger-Parker dominance  index, the biotic index characterizing the tolerance degree of aquatic organisms to eutrophication  – QMCI and water toxicity, identified by Stroganov technique. Centered calculation of the components of the MMI values is necessary to bring them to a comparable scale, as biotic indicators have different orders of values.

   The reliability of the calculated multimetric index was tested by determining the degree of difference in its values for different environmental groups of water bodies and their correlation degree with the main impact factors on the aquatic environment – the nutrient content, BOD5, water stream bottom substrate silting.

   The multimetric index obtained during this work can be recommended for application in the environmental monitoring system of inland water bodies, as well as a tool to determine the level of anthropogenic pressure on the water body for making informed decisions within the framework of sustainable development of the adjacent territories.

Keywords: multi-metric index, habitats, macroinvertibrates, benthic substrate, eutrophication, impact factors, aquatic environment monitoring.

Full text in PDF(RUS)


  1. Shitikov V. K., Zinchenko T. D. Complex criteria of ecological state of water objects: expert and statistical approach // Collection of scientific works dedicated to the memory of A. I. Bakanov. Tolyatti: Institute of ecology of the Volga basin of the Russian Academy of Sciences. 2005. P. 134-147.
  2. Barbour M.T., Stribling J.B., Karr J.R. The multimetric approach for establishing biocriteria and measuring biological condition. Chapter 6 in Biological assessment and criteria: tools for water resource planning and decision making, ed. Davis W.S. and Simon T.P. USA: Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton. P. 63–77
  3. Clapcott J.E., Goodwin, E.O., Young R.G., Kelly D.J. A multimetric approach for predicting the ecological integrity of New Zealand streams // Knowledge and Management of Aquatic Ecosystems. New Zealand. 2014. V. 415 (3). 10 p.
  4. EU Water Framework directive, European Parliament and the Council. Official Journal L 327 , 22/12/2000. Establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy.  23 October    P. 1–73.
  5. Bakanov A. I. Use of combined indices for monitoring freshwater reservoirs by zoobenthos // Water resources. 1999. Vol. 26. №1. P. 108-111.
  6. Abakumov V. A. Guide to methods of hydrobiological analysis of surface waters and bottom sediments // State Committee of the USSR for Hydrometeorology and control of the natural environment. L.: Hydrometeoizdat. 1983. P. 240.
  7. Gorbunova T. L. Using biotic indices IMC and QIMC to assess the ecological state of mountain and foothill cluster watercourses on the example of rivers in the territory of Greater Sochi // Innovations and investments. 2019. №2. P. 110-117.
  8. Shitikov V. K., Rosenberg, G. S., Zinchenko T. D. Quantitative Hydroecology: methods of system identification. Togliatti: IEBB RAS, 2003. 463.
  9. Gorbunova T. L. Use of bioindicators for assessment and monitoring of the ecological state of rivers in the coastal zone of the Black sea // Crimea-ecological and economic region. Space of noospheric development: collection of materials I Intern. environmental forum in Crimea (Sevastopol, June 2017). Sevastopol. 2017. P. 159-163.
  10. GOST R 56236-2014 (ISO 6341:2012) Water. Determination of toxicity by survival of freshwater crustaceans Daphnia magna Straus. National Standard Of The Russian Federation. Water. Date of introduction 2016-01-01. P.40.
  11. Stroganov N. S. Method of determining the toxicity of the aquatic environment // Methods of biological research / ed. Moscow, 1971. P. 14-60.
  12. Shitikov V. K., Rosenberg G. S., Zinchenko T. D. Quantitative Hydroecology: methods of system identification. Togliatti: IEBB RAS, 2003. P. 463.
  13. RD 24.309-2011 Organization and conduct of routine monitoring of the state and pollution of surface water on land. Instead of P 52.24.309-2004; introduced. June 1, 2012. Rostov n / D: Hydrometeoizdat. 2011. P.26.
  14. Feio M.J. Defining and testing targets for the recovery of tropical streams based on macroinvertebrate communities and abiotic conditions / M.J. Feio, W.R. Ferreira, D.R. Macedo [et al.] // River research and applications. 2015. V. 31 (1). P. 70–84.
  15. Buss D.F. Influence of water chemistry and environmental degradation on macroinvertebrate assemblages in a river basin in south-east Brazil / D.F. Buss, D.F. Baptista, M.P. Silveira [et al.] // Hydrobiologia. 2002. V. 481 (1–3). P. 125–136.
  16. Kyriakeas S.A., Watzin M.C. Effects of adjacent agricultural activities and watershed characteristics on stream macroinvertebrate communities // Journal of the American Water Resources Association. 2006.  42 (2). P. 425–441.
  17. Gudkova N. K., Gorbunova T. L., Lyubimtsev A. L. Identification of environmental risks associated with the development of recreational and tourist regions of the black sea coast of the Caucasus on the example of a comprehensive assessment of the ecosystem of the mountain river Laura // Sustainable development of mountain regions. 2018. Vol. 1 (35). P. 23-34.
  18. Yearbook of surface water quality of the Russian Federation. 2017. Rostov n / D: fgbu “Hydrochemical Institute”. 2018 access Mode:, free (accessed: 05.04.2019).
  19. Semenchenko V. P. Principles and systems of bioindication of flowing waters. Minsk: Nut. 2004. P. 125.
  20. Shitikov V. K., Rosenberg G. S. Assessment of biodiversity: an attempt at formal generalization // Collection of scientific works dedicated to the memory of A. I. Bakanov. Togliatti: Institute of ecology of the Volga basin, Russian Academy of Sciences. 2005. P. 91-129.
  21. Gudkova N. K., Gorbunova T. L. Assessment of impact of Adlersky landfill of solid municipal waste effluent to the river Herota biocenoses // Monitoring systems of environment. 2017. No. 9 (29). P. 115-121.
  22. Tchertoprud M. V. Rheophilic communities of macrobenthos of the North-Western Transcaucasia // Materials of the IV all-Russian Symposium on amphibiotic and aquatic insects and X Trichopterological Symposium. Vladikavkaz: North Ossetian state University. 2010. P. 131-135.
  23. Gorbunova T. L. Analysis of the toxicity of waste water from open-pit mining and enrichment of iron-titanium concentrate // Actual problems of Humanities and natural Sciences. 2017. № 6-1. P. 7-16.